Menu of Buddy's Subs in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada

Menu Overview

Buddy's Subs, located at 1920 Barton St E in Hamilton, ON, stands out as a delivery restaurant with a rich legacy, anchored by its no-frills yet inviting atmosphere. The menu reflects a deep commitment to classic subs, gyros, and fresh salads, offering a balance of traditional flavors and generous portions that have kept locals coming back for decades.

The highlight of Buddy's is undeniably their gyro offerings. Their Gyro Pita features tender, well-seasoned meat sliced right from the cone, layered with crisp lettuce, fresh onions, ripe tomatoes, and their signature tzatziki sauce. Customers like Connor Sweeney praise the juicy meat and exceptional tzatziki—an embodiment of Mediterranean flavors done right. The option to upgrade to the Super Gyro Pita means more of that succulent gyro filling, making it a fulfilling, satisfying choice.

Buddy's cold subs showcase a commendable blend of quality and value. The Ham Cold Sub and Capicola Cold Sub are crafted with fresh, crisp vegetables like lettuce and tomato, balanced by processed cheese and housemade sauces, including a unique “sun sauce” that adds a distinctive twist. Ryan’s feedback on the Footlong Club Sub highlights the fresh bread with perfect texture that holds up well under the weight of toppings and sauces. Though a bit light on meat for some tastes, the flavorful sub sauce and well-measured veggies demonstrate Buddy's talent in combining taste and texture.

Buddy’s salads, especially the Greek Salad and Gyro Salad, bring freshness to the table with chopped iceberg lettuce, ripe tomatoes, and bold feta cheese, all tossed in housemade dressings that complement without overpowering. The consistently large portions emphasize satisfaction alongside taste.

What makes Buddy's Subs truly shine is the careful attention to customer preferences—every sub or salad can be modified with increased or decreased toppings, catering to individual cravings. The friendly and efficient staff enhance the experience, making ordering seamless and personalized.

From a value perspective, this spot delivers consistent quality at reasonable prices. With decades of business behind it, Buddy’s has earned a reputation for reliability and flavor authenticity. While the decor and exterior might feel dated, these elements don’t detract from the main draw: exceptional, freshly made subs and gyros bursting with well-balanced flavors.

In conclusion, Buddy's Subs is a gem for anyone craving hearty, flavorful subs and gyros in Hamilton. The smoky, seasoned meats, fresh produce, and clever housemade sauces create an experience that’s both comforting and rewarding. Whether you're ordering the classic cold subs, the succulent gyro pitas, or a vibrant salad, Buddy's remains an enduring spot for quality, value, and genuine taste.